How Can I Get Custody if My Ex-Wife Has Been Married Four Times?

By Beverly Bird

Courts recognize a parent’s right to move on after divorce, so remarriage in itself is not usually a cause for custody modification -- even if your ex has done it three times since the two of you parted ways. However, a substantial change of circumstance is an acceptable reason to petition the court for a custody change. Depending on how your ex’s most recent marriage affects your child, this might be sufficient reason to ask a judge to give you custody.

Courts recognize a parent’s right to move on after divorce, so remarriage in itself is not usually a cause for custody modification -- even if your ex has done it three times since the two of you parted ways. However, a substantial change of circumstance is an acceptable reason to petition the court for a custody change. Depending on how your ex’s most recent marriage affects your child, this might be sufficient reason to ask a judge to give you custody.

Change of Circumstances

The courts in most states will only consider modifying custody if the parent seeking the change can prove that something major has occurred to affect the status quo. The change must usually have occurred in the custodial parent’s home where the child lives most of the time. Courts strongly favor stability in a child’s life and usually won’t force a child to move from one home to another after custody has been established, at least not without good reason. However, if new spouses are regularly moving in and out of your ex’s home, this isn’t conducive to a stable environment for your child.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Retroactivity Issues

If your ex was married twice before she met you, married and divorced you, then remarried again, it’s highly unlikely that a court would hold this against her and modify custody as a result. A different type of change in circumstances must have occurred since the court issued your existing custody order. If you want to use your ex-wife’s penchant for marrying against her in a custody dispute, for example, by implying that it says something about her morals or psychological stability, the time for that would have been when the judge was initially deciding custody in your divorce proceedings. If your ex has only remarried once more since divorcing you, her new spouse might enhance her suitability as a parent. If he has a good relationship with your child and brings added financially stability to your ex’s home, a court might see her latest marriage in a positive light.

Effect on Child

If your ex’s current spouse is abusive toward your child, her remarriage would be a change of circumstance that would probably affect a court’s decision. If you can prove the abuse or a negative home environment because of the remarriage, it’s likely a judge would move your child from your ex’s home to yours to protect him. If your ex has been married three more times since you broke up, you might also be able to make the case that a “revolving door” of spouses moving in and out of your ex’s home and bedroom is detrimental to your child’s emotional health. You must usually prove these types of issues unequivocally for a judge to change custody.

Child’s Preference

According to the American Bar Association at the time of publication, only two states -- Massachusetts and Vermont -- do not consider a child’s preference in custody matters in any respect. Of the remaining 48 states, some give a child’s wishes far more weight than others, especially as the child grows older. If your child is a teenager and he is distressed by the frequency with which his mother remarries, speak with an attorney to find out how your particular state will take his feelings into consideration. If he’s older and your state allows it, his desire to modify custody and live with you might be the deciding factor in a custody change, not your ex's habit of remarrying.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Remarriage & Custody

References

Related articles

Divorce & Changes in Circumstance in Massachusetts

Ideally, if a significant change occurs in your life, it will happen while you are in mid-divorce, so your eventual decree can adequately address it. This isn't usually the case, and Massachusetts allows spouses to modify the terms of their decrees after divorce to accommodate changes. However, unless you and your spouse agree to a modification by consent, Massachusetts judges require “substantial and material” changes in circumstance before they’ll issue a modification order. “Substantial” means the change must be big; “material” means it must directly relate to the provision you want to change.

Dad's Rights to Sole Custody

Fathers had few rights in custody battles in the 20th century. That changed somewhat in the millennium. However, the change takes the form of courts being willing to at least consider giving a father sole physical custody, with his children living with him and having minimal contact or visitation with their mother. Fathers still face an uphill battle in actually achieving sole custody of their children.

What Do You Need for a Custody Lawsuit?

All lawsuits come down to proof. A litigant who is able to substantiate his position because he's backed it up with concrete, tangible evidence has a much better chance of success than one who doesn't. When something as important as your child's welfare is at stake, you’ll want to begin documenting your position early on, as soon as you suspect you and your ex might end up in a courtroom.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

Can You Go Back to Court for Custody After You Gave Your Child to Your Spouse?

Parents always maintain the right to go back to court to change custody arrangements after their divorce is final. The ...

How Fathers Can Win Custody

In 1999, research indicated that mothers received custody 91.2 percent of the time when parents went to court over ...

How Is Child Custody Decided In Divorce?

Every state defers to a concept called the “best interests of the child” when deciding custody issues. But ...

What Happens to Child Support & Alimony When a Divorcee Remarries?

Approximately half of all Americans remarry within five years of divorce, according to U.S. Census Bureau in a 2006 ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED