How to Check the Legitimacy of a Charity

By Tom Streissguth

Giving to charity is a worthy deed, but donor beware: not all charities are legitimate and not all groups use their funds for purposes advertised. There are convenient methods to check on a group to verify its self-marketing as a charitable organization. The key to this process is to investigate financial statements given to the IRS, to state agencies and as provided on informational web sites.

Giving to charity is a worthy deed, but donor beware: not all charities are legitimate and not all groups use their funds for purposes advertised. There are convenient methods to check on a group to verify its self-marketing as a charitable organization. The key to this process is to investigate financial statements given to the IRS, to state agencies and as provided on informational web sites.

IRS Forms and Reports

A legitimate charity uses donations for the purpose it advertises, whether it's shelter for the homeless, medical care for the indigent or disaster relief. To find out how your group is using its money, request a copy of Form 990, the annual return that all non-profit groups must file with the Internal Revenue Service. Churches, synagogues and other houses of worship are exempt from this requirement but may still volunteer the information.

Get a free, confidential bankruptcy evaluation. Learn More

Websites

You can also investigate by navigating to online sites that provide ratings and reviews of non-profit groups. Donors, volunteers and those who benefit from the charity may all have something important to say. The big daddy of these websites is Charity Navigator, which offers reports on accountability and spending. The site breaks down charities by category (Animals, Environment, Health etc.) and gives star ratings, reviews and 1-through-70 scores in two categories: Financial Health, and Accountability and Transparency. The Better Business Bureau also hosts a webpage on charities and bestows the BBB Charity Seal on groups that pass its Standards for Charity Accountability.

Financials and State Agencies

Request a copy of the group's financial statements. They're not required by law to provide these publicly, but a legitimate non-profit won't mind responding to an individual's request for information. If this proves difficult, contact the state agency that oversees non-profit and charitable groups operating in the state (often, the Secretary of State), and ask for a copy of audited financial statements from the group you're investigating. In addition, the state attorney general may keep a database of complaints and lawsuits directed against the charity.

Costs and Expenses

Keep in mind some basic financial ratios that provide an idea of how the charity operates. Compare the earnings of the CEO to the budget for programs and check the office and administrative costs as a percentage of overall expenses. The higher these numbers and ratios, the less efficient the charity is. A legitimate charity is not run for the benefit of its leader or directors; instead, the majority of its spending goes to its beneficiaries.

Get a free, confidential bankruptcy evaluation. Learn More
How to Know if a Charitable Organization in Maryland Is Legitimate?

References

Related articles

IRS and Laws Prohibiting Nonprofits From Political Activity

Federal tax laws prohibit nonprofit organizations from engaging in partisan political activity. Tax-exempt organizations may run afoul of the Internal Revenue Service if those groups take part in political campaigns for or against a candidate for public office. Nonprofits that violate IRS guidelines and U.S. laws prohibiting nonprofits from partisan political activity risk losing their tax-exempt status and may also incur tax penalties.

Charity Vs. 501(c)(3)

All 501(c)(3) organizations are a type of charity. However, not all charities decide to file for 501(c)(3) status, and may not be required to do so. There are benefits for any nonprofit in filing for 501(c)(3) status, but there is a detailed application and a number of obligations that come with that IRS designation.

Executive Pay Guidelines for Nonprofits

The rules for setting up nonprofit organizations are based on state statute and therefore differ from state to state. Currently, neither state nor federal law provides for a monetary cap on executive compensation, and the arm of the IRS reaches only as far as the reporting and disclosure aspect of compensation and profit.

Related articles

Non-Profit Requirements for Non-Cash Donations

Encouraging donations is an important part of ensuring the success of a non-profit organization. In order to avoid ...

How to Find 501(C)(3) Tax Exempt Companies

To obtain a 501(c)(3) tax exempt status, most nonprofit companies must file documents with the IRS proving they operate ...

What Is a 501(c)(3) Determination Letter?

The Internal Revenue Service sets down the tax rules for nonprofit corporations, including the charitable organizations ...

Grants for 501(C)(3) Organizations

A nonprofit organization with 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status may qualify for various grants to help it carry out its ...

Browse by category