Child's Preference in a Divorce

By Heather Frances J.D.

During a divorce, children often want to express their wishes about custody, especially if they have a stronger preference to live with one parent instead of the other. Depending on the child’s age, his maturity and your state's laws, your divorce court may consider your child’s preferences. However, laws vary among states, so there is no one-size-fits-all answer.

During a divorce, children often want to express their wishes about custody, especially if they have a stronger preference to live with one parent instead of the other. Depending on the child’s age, his maturity and your state's laws, your divorce court may consider your child’s preferences. However, laws vary among states, so there is no one-size-fits-all answer.

Best Interests Standard

All state courts base their custody decisions on what is in the best interests of the child, so arrangements may vary among jurisdictions, judges, and even families. Many states' laws mention the child’s preference as one aspect of determining the child’s best interests. Some states specifically list the child’s preference as a factor for the judge to consider, whereas others may allow the judge to consider it as part of the whole family picture. Even if the child indicates a strong preference, judges may ignore the child’s preference if it would not be in the child’s best interests to live with that parent.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Age

Many state laws are vague about the age at which a child is considered old enough to make a decision about where he wants to live. This allows the court to consider the maturity and circumstances of each child. Generally, courts give more weight to the opinion of older children. In Georgia and West Virginia, state laws specify that a child, once he reaches age 14, has a right to choose the parent with whom he wishes to live. However, even these statutes do not allow a child to live with an unfit parent.

Weighing Preference

Unless state law specifically requires the judge to consider the child’s preference when determining what custody arrangement is in the child’s best interests, a judge may not give the child’s preference any weight if the child prefers one parent simply because that parent is more lenient or because that parent has tried to buy his preference. For example, if a parent promises a child new toys or vacations to entice the child to indicate a preference for living with her, the judge may disregard the child’s preference entirely. Your judge may interview your child privately to get a clearer picture of the child’s motives.

Adult Children

When a child reaches the age of majority in his state, he has the right to choose the parent with whom he wants to live. Court orders for custody no longer apply once a child becomes a legal adult, even if the child is attending college or otherwise still living at home and depending on his parents for support. Similarly, if the child is emancipated, he can choose where he wants to live since he has all the legal rights of an adult.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
What Age Do Children in Utah Have Rights to Choose Which Parent to Live With in a Divorce?

References

Related articles

Arizona Teenager Rights in a Divorce

Although most kids don't want to hear it, they have very few rights when their parents divorce – particularly the right to a voice in the proceedings. They're entitled to support and care, just as all children are, and Arizona law makes provisions for this when their parents break up. Teens can't call their own shots, however -- at least unless they emancipate themselves.

When Can a Child Decide to Live With the Other Divorced Parent by Washington State Law?

In many states, including Washington, courts in custody cases may consider the wishes of a child in terms of which parent he would prefer to live with after the divorce is granted. However, according to the American Bar Association, only two states, Georgia and West Virginia, give a child who is 14 or older the absolute right to decide which parent he's going to live with. In every other state, the judge decides where a child will live according to the "best interests of the child" standard. In short, a child in Washington state can express his preference to the court, but a judge decides where he will reside by designating one parent as the "primary residential parent."

How Old Must a Minor Be in Kentucky Before He Has a Say in Custody & Visitation?

Parents are often vocal about their preferences in a custody battle. However, a child also may have an opinion about which parent he would rather live with. In Kentucky, although the courts consider a child's choice in custody and visitation matters, the amount of weight given to the preference depends on his maturity level and the specific circumstances of the case.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

What Age Can a Child Decide Custody?

Most state courts are well aware that children – particularly teenagers – can have firm feelings of their ...

Divorce in Maryland: Can a Child Choose Where to Live?

It's hard enough for adults to accept that a divorce court can decide when and how they see their children. Telling a ...

14 Year Olds' Rights in Custody Hearings in Arizona

Custody disputes are often hardest on children, the very people for whom the disputing parties claim to advocate on ...

The Legal Age in California for Choosing to Live With Your Mom or Your Dad

California courts base child custody decisions on the legal doctrine known as "the best interests of the ...

Browse by category