Fair Use Exceptions to Copyright Law

By Jennifer Mueller

Under the copyright law, the creator of the original work is known as its author. U.S. Copyright law provides authors the exclusive right to reproduce, distribute, perform, display, and prepare derivative works of their original expression in a tangible medium. The fair use doctrine limits these rights, and acknowledges that in certain cases, the needs of the public outweigh the copyright owner’s rights. Fair use allows for certain uses of copyrighted work without license or payment to the copyright holder. Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act lists four factors courts must weigh in deciding whether a use is fair.

Under the copyright law, the creator of the original work is known as its author. U.S. Copyright law provides authors the exclusive right to reproduce, distribute, perform, display, and prepare derivative works of their original expression in a tangible medium. The fair use doctrine limits these rights, and acknowledges that in certain cases, the needs of the public outweigh the copyright owner’s rights. Fair use allows for certain uses of copyrighted work without license or payment to the copyright holder. Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act lists four factors courts must weigh in deciding whether a use is fair.

Fair Use as a Defense

Copyright infringement occurs when someone reproduces, distributes, performs, publicly displays, or makes a derivative of a work without the copyright owner's permission. Fair use is an affirmative defense to copyright infringement. A copyright holder may sue someone for infringement of his copyright. Provided the copyright holder proves infringement is likely, the alleged infringer may raise the defense of fair use. The defendant has the burden of proof on all elements of the defense, and must address the purpose of his use, the nature of the copyrighted work used, the amount of the copyrighted work he copied, and the market effect of his usage. If the defendant successfully proves his use was fair, the court will rule no infringement has occurred.

Protect against infringement by registering a copyright. Get Started Now

Copier's Purpose

Defendants of a copyright infringement must first explain the character and purpose of their use of the copyrighted work. Courts are more likely to consider a use fair if that use was for an educational purpose, such as copying materials for research purposes or showing a film in a classroom. Courts are less likely to consider a use fair if the copyrighted work was used for commercial or entertainment reasons. Using a copyrighted work to provide commentary or criticism of that work is also usually considered fair use.

Nature of Copyrighted Work

Further, defendants of infringement must address the nature of the copyrighted work they used. Courts are more apt to find the use was fair if the copyrighted work is less creative, and deals with facts rather than fiction. A copyrighted work that has not yet been published is more stringently protected against fair use than one that has already been published. Courts reason authors have the right to determine when and how their work should be published in the first instance.

Amount of Work Copied

Defendants of copyright infringement must also note the amount of the copyrighted work they used. How much of the copyrighted work was used is a qualitative and quantitative analysis. Quantitatively, fair use of a work generally entails using as little of the copyrighted work as possible for the user to achieve her purpose. Qualitatively, courts are less likely to consider a use fair if the piece taken from the copyrighted work, no matter how small, represents the very heart of the work.

Market Effect of Copying

Finally, defendants should demonstrate what effect their use had, or potentially will have, on the market for the original copyrighted work. Courts are more likely to consider a use fair if the defendant can prove his usage had, or potentially will have, little to no negative value on the public’s demand for the copyrighted work. Courts also analyze access to the work; use is more likely to be considered fair if there is restricted access, as opposed to the work being offered without limitation to the general public.

Common Examples of Fair Use

Fair use is most often found in cases where the purpose was for critique or parody. Critique demands portions of a work be copied, perhaps even the heart of it, for a critique to be effective. Similarly, a successful parody of a work demands large portions of that work be copied. If these uses have any effect on the demand for the original work, they tend to increase rather than decrease demand for the original work. Courts also reason most copyright holders would not provide permission for their work to be used in these ways.

Protect against infringement by registering a copyright. Get Started Now
What Is Copyright Infraction?

References

Related articles

Copyright Laws & Guidelines

There are many laws and guidelines related to applying for copyright registration, the basis for bringing a lawsuit for copyright infringement and what constitutes fair use under copyright law. Although most copyright law is established by the United States Copyright Code and common law applications by judges, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act relates more directly to modern applications of the law. Copyright laws are codified by statute, but many other copyright guidelines exist, such as the first sale doctrine and the doctrine of fair use.

For Profit Vs. Non-Profit Copyright Laws & Fair Use Issues

"Fair use" is one of the most important exceptions to copyright law -- and one of the most widely misunderstood. This is not surprising, since it is also one of the murkiest areas of copyright law. You can be sued for violation of the fair use exception even if your use of copyrighted material is non-commercial.

Copyright & Fair Use Guidelines for School Projects

Using materials created by other people in a school project isn't necessarily a violation of the copyright laws. Students routinely lift images from web pages to illustrate a science project or quote passages from books in class papers. While the copyright law often protects such materials, the act of copying them may be protected by the fair use exception of the copyright law.

Related articles

Can I Record Someone Else's Song and Change the Words in Parody Law?

United States copyright law grants legal protection to various creative works, including songs or lyrics. Under The ...

Can You Use Copyrighted Photos as Sermon Illustrations?

A copyright issued by the U.S. Copyright Office protects original creative works, including literary, musical, dramatic ...

The Most Important Limitations of Fair Use Copyright Laws

"Fair use" is a doctrine in copyright law that can be used as a defense to unlicensed use of a copyrighted ...

Fair Use Copyright Laws for Education

Copyright laws restrict individuals from using, copying or otherwise reproducing copyrighted materials without ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED