If a Party to a Divorce in California Violates a Court Order: Can They Be Held Accountable?

By David Carnes

California courts, like the courts in all states, have the power to issue orders to the parties in a lawsuit, including parties to a divorce. Willful violation of a court order is an offense known as “contempt of court.” California courts may issue various orders with respect to a divorce proceeding, including orders compelling all parties to comply with the court’s previous directives.

California courts, like the courts in all states, have the power to issue orders to the parties in a lawsuit, including parties to a divorce. Willful violation of a court order is an offense known as “contempt of court.” California courts may issue various orders with respect to a divorce proceeding, including orders compelling all parties to comply with the court’s previous directives.

Orders Subject to Contempt Penalties

Because contempt of court carries a potential penalty of imprisonment, not all legal obligations are subject to court orders enforceable by contempt of court. A routine money judgment, for example, cannot be enforced by contempt of court sanctions because the Constitution bans imprisonment for debt. A number of divorce-related issues that involve the payment of money or relinquishment of assets can be enforced by contempt of court sanctions, however. A court may impose contempt penalties for failure to comply with an order for child support; failure to pay court costs; failure to pay the other spouse's attorneys' fees; failure to comply with the court-ordered division of marital property between spouses; failure to honor court-ordered assignment of marital debts; and in some cases, failure to comply with a marital settlement agreement. Other types of divorce-related issues enforceable by contempt of court penalties include orders regarding child custody and visitation, restraining orders and financial disclosure requirements.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Defenses

A successful prosecution for contempt of court requires that the defendant willfully disobey a court order of which he was aware and capable of complying with. The defendant may assert numerous defenses under California law. Defenses include an assertion that failure to comply was unintentional, the defendant didn't know about the court order (for example, he didn't attend the hearing and his attorney failed to inform him), he lacked the ability to comply with the order, or the assertion of noncompliance is false.

Enforcement Procedures

To initiate a prosecution for contempt of court, the aggrieved party must file an Order to Show Cause and Affidavit for Contempt (Family Law) with the family law court that issued the relevant order. These forms are available on the California Courts website. The affidavit must be personally served on the defendant. The family court will convene a hearing, and divorce proceedings will be suspended until the contempt charge is resolved. The defendant is entitled to attend the hearing and to be represented by an attorney. Because of potential criminal liability, he is entitled to criminal law protections under the Constitution, such as the right to remain silent to avoid self-incrimination. Guilt must be established beyond a reasonable doubt rather than by a mere "preponderance of evidence," a lower standard of proof that applies to civil proceedings.

Penalties

Penalties for contempt of court include up to five days in jail for each count. This can add up quickly – for example, each month for which a defendant fails to pay child support can be treated as a separate count. Alternatively, the court may sentence a defendant to up to 120 hours of community service per count. Repeat offenders can be sanctioned by up to 10 days in jail or 240 hours of community service per count. If the conviction for contempt resulted from the defendant's failure to perform an act that he is still able to perform, the court may simply order him imprisoned until he performs it. In California, the statute of limitations for contempt is two years after the act or omission that constituted the contempt occurred.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Post Divorce Contempt Issues

References

Resources

Related articles

The Penalties for Not Paying Alimony in Illinois

In Illinois, alimony is known as spousal maintenance and is an important tool for ensuring that former spouses can maintain their lifestyle after a divorce. In Illinois, failure to pay spousal maintenance can invoke significant penalties. Prior to pursuing a remedy through courts, it may be a good idea for an ex-spouse not receiving payment to speak to her former spouse first. Attempting to resolve the issue outside of court may save both time and expense, and result in the ex-spouse receiving her maintenance payments faster.

What Happens if an Ex-Spouse Breaks Divorce Decrees in Tennessee?

Tennessee is one of the more unforgiving states when someone defies a court order, including a divorce decree. Penalties are multi-pronged, depending on how your ex breaks the terms of the decree. They range from paying your court and attorney fees to suspension of his driver’s license and even jail time.

What to Do if You Are Named in a Divorce Petition

A third party or co-litigant named in a divorce petition should review the allegations and file a responsive pleading right away. If the third party does not respond to the allegations, the court could make a potentially damaging ruling in his absence. In general, if a person is named as a third-party in a divorce petition, his participation is considered absolutely necessary to resolve the dispute. Third parties are often named for purposes of dividing property or proving allegations of adultery within the marriage.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

What Happens if You Breach an LLC Operating Agreement?

A limited liability company, or LLC, is usually governed by an operating agreement. Most states do not require that ...

Reasons for Contempt in Divorce Court

Contempt occurs when a person fails to comply with a court order. Settlement agreements signed by a judge, standardized ...

What You Need to Know About Child Support Court in California

Child support payments can create turmoil during California divorce proceedings. A number of issues exist, including ...

What Are Sanctions in a Divorce Case?

Sanctions during a divorce proceeding are penalties for bad behavior by a spouse or his attorney during a divorce. ...

Browse by category