Texas Family Law Code Proof of Cruelty

By Jim Thomas

You can get a divorce in Texas if your spouse is "guilty of cruel treatment" towards you, if that treatment makes "further living together insupportable." The statute does not directly address what type of proof is necessary to show that living together is "insupportable." However, Texas case law provides some guidance.

You can get a divorce in Texas if your spouse is "guilty of cruel treatment" towards you, if that treatment makes "further living together insupportable." The statute does not directly address what type of proof is necessary to show that living together is "insupportable." However, Texas case law provides some guidance.

Defining Cruelty

The bitter divorce case of Newberry v. Newberry, which wound up in the Texas Court of Appeals in 2011, resulted in a lengthy discussion of Texas case law regarding the type and degree of proof necessary to establish cruelty. The appeals court upheld a family court finding of cruelty against Ruel Newberry, who allegedly had sex with an old girlfriend during the marriage and was repeatedly found with pornographic materials in the home.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Proving Cruelty

Texas courts have defined "insupportable" as "incapable of being borne, unendurable, insufferable, intolerable." Previous family court decisions have held that physical abuse constitutes cruelty. Excessive and outrageous non-physical treatment of a spouse can be sufficient to constitute cruelty. Adultery has been deemed sufficient for a finding of cruelty. Several different acts of lesser forms of cruelty may be enough for a court to grant a divorce on cruelty grounds. However, making your spouse nervous or embarrassed doesn't rise to the legal level of cruelty.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
What Is Cruelty in Grounds for Divorce in Maryland?

References

Related articles

Defense of Justification in Divorce

Some states no longer recognize fault-based divorces, but others still allow spouses to get a divorce based on fault grounds. In those states, if a spouse makes allegations of fault in her divorce complaint, such as adultery or cruelty, she must prove them to the court's satisfaction. Her spouse has the right to try to deny her allegations. This is called defense of justification, or sometimes an affirmative defense. The accused spouse can essentially offer an excuse for his wrongdoing in an attempt to exonerate himself.

Does Having a Criminal Record Affect Divorce in Massachusetts?

It is well established that the divorce process gets highly personal in nature. In Massachusetts, the degree to which the conduct of a spouse can affect a custody award depends on many factors, and goes beyond whether or not a parent has a criminal conviction. Certain serious felonies and domestic violence weigh heavily against awarding custody, but evidence of parental fitness may overcome this. Understanding what factors a judge will look to for guidance when making custody determinations, as well as knowing when a criminal record can affect aspects of the divorce, may help remove some confusion surrounding custody in Massachusetts.

How Does Spouse Abuse Affect Child Custody?

Courts and parents alike want to keep children safe from harm. In determining the custody arrangement following a divorce, courts are primarily concerned with what is in the best interest of the child. As a result, a history of abuse by a parent, particularly if the history is documented, may be highly influential in the outcome of a custody case.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

What Constitutes Mental Cruelty in a Divorce?

In 2010, New York became the 50th state to adopt a no-fault divorce law, which generally eliminates the need to use ...

Divorce Law & Intolerable Severity in Vermont

You may have many reasons for your divorce, but a Vermont court cannot grant your divorce petition unless your reasons ...

How Does Georgia Define Verbal Abuse in a Divorce Case?

Georgia law allows couples to divorce due to verbal abuse, but only if the abuse rises to the level of "cruel ...

Grounds for Divorce on Mental Cruelty in Illinois

While marital discord is often mutual, sometimes one spouse bears the brunt of intentional and unreasonable mental and ...

Browse by category