How to Understand Copyright Ideas Versus Expression

By Lee Roberts

In the United States, copyright laws stem from a simple statement in the Constitution that gives exclusive rights to authors to protect their original works which, in turn, promotes the progress of science and useful arts. Copyright laws look primarily at the form of the work, to distinguish between protected and unprotected works. Copyright tries to reward individual authors while still addressing the public’s needs and concerns regarding intellectual property.

In the United States, copyright laws stem from a simple statement in the Constitution that gives exclusive rights to authors to protect their original works which, in turn, promotes the progress of science and useful arts. Copyright laws look primarily at the form of the work, to distinguish between protected and unprotected works. Copyright tries to reward individual authors while still addressing the public’s needs and concerns regarding intellectual property.

Requirements

Authors acquire the rights in an original work as soon as they fix the work in a tangible form of expression. A fixed form includes standard written or drawn forms as well as those that humans cannot read or interpret directly without the aid of a machine or device. Neither lawmakers nor the courts have defined originality with precision. As a general matter, originality means the author originated a work that contains more creativity than a simple compilation of facts.

Protect against infringement by registering a copyright. Get Started Now

Fixed Format

You satisfy the fixed format requirement when you write your idea on paper, paint it on a canvas, record it with a camera or perform a host of other common actions to express yourself in a tangible manner. You can test if your work meets the requirement if you copy your idea into a material object that someone can read or perceive visually. Phonorecords are the means by which you can fix sounds into material objects. Statutes broadly define phonorecords to include cassette tapes, CDs, DVDs and vinyl disks.

Expression

Copyright laws do not protect you from other people who may copy your ideas. As a practical matter, it is very difficult to determine who may have had an idea first. It is also difficult to establish the specific content of your idea if it is not in a form that someone else can read, hear or see. Putting your unexpressed ideas into tangible form provides a set point from which the time begins to run on your exclusive rights over the work.

Using Ideas

Copyright law protects the expression of mundane ideas as thoroughly as it does extraordinary ideas. Requiring authors to express their ideas by putting them into something tangible frees everyone else to generate ideas without the fear that they will need to defend themselves against a lawsuit for infringement simply based on the similarity of ideas. Even after you express an idea in fixed form, the idea itself does not fall under copyright protection, but fixed forms that contain your idea are. Others may take the same idea and use it for their own purposes. Einstein's theory of relativity is an idea and not copyrightable, but papers he wrote about it are copyrightable. Therefore, others can use Einstein's theory and create other copyrightable essays about his theory.

Protect against infringement by registering a copyright. Get Started Now
Can Therapeutic Techniques Be Copyrighted?

References

Resources

Related articles

Copyright Laws on Exercise Routines

Title 17 of the U.S. Code extends copyright protection to original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works. Exercise routines that fall within any of these categories may be registered with the U.S. Copyright Office. Copyright does not extend to ideas or concepts that have not been fixed in a tangible form. To benefit from copyright protection, the creator of an original routine must therefore either write it down or record it in a video or multimedia format.

The Disadvantages of Copyrights

Copyright is a form of protection that attaches to an original work of authorship the moment the work of authorship is fixed in a tangible form: for example, a drawing the moment it is put onto paper or a song the moment it is recorded onto a compact disk. The advantages of copyright protection overwhelmingly outweigh the disadvantages. There are nevertheless several disadvantages to keep in mind.

Originality and Copyright Laws

Copyright laws protect a wide range of works, including novels, songs, photographs, movies and computer programs. A copyright holder can file an infringement lawsuit against anyone who uses his work without permission. The issue of originality usually arises in an infringement lawsuit when the defendant claims that the copyright is invalid because the work is not original.

Related articles

Does a Copyright Protect an Author's Creative Idea?

Copyright laws give authors and other creators property rights for their works of original authorship, including the ...

How to Prevent Others From Infringing on Your Copyright

Copyright is the scheme of legal protection for people who develop original creative works including art, literature, ...

Joint Authorship & Copyright

Copyright is the legal protection afforded to creators of original works like writings, paintings, or musical ...

Copyrighted Book Laws

The book publishing industry is changing rapidly, but copyright laws continue to protect the rights of authors, whether ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED