Can a Lover Be Forced to Testify at a Divorce if the Affair Is Known?

By Beverly Bird

As a general rule, if someone has an affair with a married individual, she should brace herself for an appearance in divorce court. Ultimately, however, it comes down to the rules in your particular state. If you live in one of the jurisdictions that does not recognize fault grounds, the issue of adultery is often moot. Otherwise, if your spouse files on grounds of adultery, she must prove her allegations through testimony and other evidence.

Fault vs. No-Fault Proceedings

Because no-fault divorce is much easier than proving fault grounds, testimony from a lover may not happen -- particularly if there's no advantage in proving adultery for the wronged spouse. For example, in New Jersey, adultery typically doesn't affect alimony or property division, so a lover's testimony at trial might be pointless. If you live in Virginia, however, issues of adultery can affect a claim for alimony, so it might be worth it for your spouse to prove the adultery and have your lover testify.

Service of Process

If you had an affair and you're now facing divorce, your paramour will probably know relatively early on in the proceedings if your spouse has implicated her. Some states, such as New Jersey, require that she be served with a copy of the divorce complaint if your spouse files on fault grounds of adultery, and the complaint must name her as the individual with whom you committed adultery. Your lover usually has a right to respond to the allegations. She can file her own pleadings in response, denying the charges. A denial may not save her from being called as a witness at trial, however.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Proving Adultery

If your spouse files for divorce on grounds of adultery, the burden of proof is entirely on her. She typically does not have produce direct evidence, however. Circumstantial evidence is acceptable in most states. She must usually establish at least two things: that you had the inclination to cheat, and that you had the opportunity to do so. Your lover's testimony can be used to corroborate or bolster your spouse's circumstantial evidence.

Witness Testimony

Divorcing spouses have the right to call any witness at trial if the individual possesses information that is pertinent to the case. Courts will generally agree that your paramour possesses pertinent information. Your spouse would have to subpoena your lover and provide her name as an anticipated witness prior to trial. Some state courts put more weight on a paramour's testimony than others. For example, Mississippi is willing to accept the testimony of a paramour as stand-alone proof.

Other Evidence

Other acceptable evidence that corroborates or complements a paramour's testimony can cover a wide range. Your spouse might present photographs of the two of you snuggling in public, emails, text messages, or even the testimony of other witnesses who saw the two of you together. When it's all added up, this evidence may successfully prove adultery grounds.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
How to Prove Adultery for Divorce in South Carolina

References

Related articles

Subpoenaing Witnesses for a Divorce Trial

A successful divorce trial is the result of gathering and documenting information. If you and your spouse cannot reach a settlement and a trial becomes inevitable, you will probably want to seek the assistance of an attorney, rather than proceed on your own. Your attorney will first attempt to identify facts that will support your case through discovery methods. These might include issuing interrogatories, which are written questions your spouse must answer under oath. Then your attorney must bring these facts to the attention of the judge. One way to accomplish the latter is to subpoena the person who holds the information, legally obligating them to give testimony.

How Long for an Uncontested Divorce in Louisiana If a Spouse Committed Adultery?

In Louisiana, a divorce is uncontested when both spouses agree on the terms of the divorce, such as custody, spousal support and property division. For a no-fault divorce, Louisiana law requires that the spouses go through a waiting period. However, when one spouse proves adultery, which is a fault ground, the divorcing spouses do not have to go through a waiting period before the divorce is final.

How to Prove At-Fault Divorce in Pennsylvania

Fault-based divorces are somewhat rare in Pennsylvania, especially since the state legislature amended Pennsylvania's Divorce Code in 2005, permitting couples to divorce by mutual consent, a form of no-fault divorce. Pennsylvania courts don’t consider marital misconduct when dividing property, so the consent option is usually the easiest, least stressful and least expensive method by which to end a marriage. If you nevertheless want to file for divorce on fault grounds, Pennsylvania law does not make the process easy.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

New York Laws on a Divorce Adultery Countersuit

New York has recognized no-fault grounds for divorce since 2010, but this doesn’t prevent a spouse from filing on fault ...

Adultery Divorce Laws

In 2010, New York became the last state in the country to adopt no-fault divorce. No matter where you live, you no ...

Can Documents Obtained by a Private Investigator Be Requested as a Discovery in a Divorce Case?

If you suspect that your soon-to-be ex will go to any and all lengths to dig up information to influence your divorce ...

What If You Don't Admit to Adultery in a Divorce Case?

Deciding whether to admit to adultery during divorce proceedings is a personal decision, and one that ultimately, will ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED