Can You Patent Ideas or Theories?

By Christopher Faille

There is a long-standing legal principle in the United States, based on but not explicitly found in the language of the Patent Act, that "abstract ideas" cannot provide subject matter for a valid patent. What exactly this means is quite unclear. Litigants and courts have to thrash it out, case by case.

Statutory Language

A first screen for what is patentable subject matter is the wording of section 101 of the Patent Act, which requires a "new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof." This language excludes what one might call a "useless" idea or theory, but to the extent an idea or theory can be both new and useful, and to the extent it is embodied in a machine, manufacture, or so forth, it passes this threshold.

Supreme Court

The Supreme Court, in a line of precedents going back to 1852, has long held that "abstract" ideas are not patentable. In the case it heard that year, the patent holder claimed as its invention a certain combination of techniques used to create pipes out of lead. In the course of a wide-ranging discussion, the court said: "A principle, in the abstract, is a fundamental truth; an original cause; a motive; these cannot be patented...."

File a provisional application for patent online. Get Started Now

More Recent Application

What ideas are too abstract to be patentable remains a commonly litigated issue in the 21st century. In 2010, the Supreme Court decided against two men (Bilski and Warsaw) who had together filed a patent application on a method of hedging risk in the purchase of energy-related commodities such as coal or natural gas. The court said that this was a mere abstract idea.

Few Bright Lines

The Supreme Court's Bilski decision didn't give any definitive test for abstractness, and it specifically rejected some possible bright-line standards. For example, it would not say that "business methods" in general cannot be patented. The statute "leaves open the possibility that there are at least some processes that can be fairly described as business methods that are within patentable subject matter under section 101." Though there are still few bright lines, the general trend in recent years has been toward a narrower understanding of what is patentable, a broader understanding of some of the doctrinal limits such as the exclusion of abstract ideas.

Laws of Nature

A related idea is that "laws of nature" are not subject to patent. For example, it is an observed fact that the human body metabolizes certain substances in a predictable way. Nobody can own that regularity/law. No one, then, can enforce a patent for a medical procedure that consists entirely of observing the effects of that regularity.

File a provisional application for patent online. Get Started Now
Can Products Be Similar Without Violating Patent Laws?


Related articles

What Violates a Patent?

Innovation drives success but also can breed danger. If you make or sell a device or process that resembles a patented invention, and you have not first secured the patent holder’s permission, you could be found guilty of patent infringement, even if your violation was unintentional. Violating a patent is a serious offense that can take several forms and it carries stiff penalties. To avoid an infringement lawsuit, know beforehand what actions violate a patent and seek professional counsel if in doubt. In the words of patent attorney William Ramsey, “Every person has a duty to avoid patent infringement.”

Examples of Patents

President George Washington signed the first American patent granted to Samuel Hopkins in 1790 for a product used to manufacture fertilizer. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office now recognizes more than six million patents. A legal patent protects the use of the invention by other Americans and residents of countries recognizing international patent laws.

What Needs a Patent: An Idea or An Invention?

When you have a great idea, you'll be tempted to patent the idea as soon as possible. However, simply having a great idea isn't enough to file for a patent. You'll need to meet a number of very specific requirements before you can start the patent application process and eventually obtain a patent.

Start here. LegalZoom. Legal help is here. LLCs. Corporations. Patents. Attorney help. Patents

Related articles

Elements of a Patent

A patent gives an inventor the legal right to prevent others from making, using or selling the inventor’s new device, ...

How to Cite a Patent Application

A patent is a type of intellectual property right granted by the U.S. government. Patents allow inventors to prevent ...

What Is Gene Patenting?

A patent is a legal protection that allows an inventor to reap the exclusive economic benefits of her invention for a ...

Does a Copyright Protect an Author's Creative Idea?

Copyright laws give authors and other creators property rights for their works of original authorship, including the ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED