Can a Trust Override a Beneficiary in an IRA Bank Account?

By John Stevens J.D.

A trust is a legal device by which property is distributed to beneficiaries named in the trust. Although property held in a trust usually does not require probate, trusts are not the only way in which probate can be bypassed. Many assets, including IRA accounts, allow the holder to name a beneficiary that automatically receives the property upon the death of the property owner. Generally, a beneficiary designation will override the trust provisions. There are situations, however, in which the beneficiary designation will fail and the proceeds of the account will pass under the terms of the trust.

The Requirement of Mental Capacity

A person who makes a legal decision must have the mental capacity to understand the result of that action. The distinct circumstances of the action make a difference, however. For example, if a person was an alcoholic but was not under the influence of alcohol when he acted, alcoholism would likely have little bearing on whether he had mental capacity. Designating a beneficiary of an IRA account is a legal decision. If the person who designated the beneficiary lacked the mental capacity to make that decision at the time the decision was made, a court would likely invalidate that designation. Assuming that the person had mental capacity at the time of signing a trust, the trust provisions would then override that beneficiary designation.

Fraud

Fraud can result not only in civil liability, but also in criminal liability. Fraud occurs when a person intentionally misrepresents important facts, and that misrepresentation causes a person to do something, or not to do something. For example, suppose that a son tells his mother that she needs to sign some paperwork for her doctor, and that the mother signs the document. If the document instead changed the beneficiary designation on the mother’s IRA account, and if the son intentionally misrepresented the nature of the document to his mother, that beneficiary designation could be void. If the mother had a trust, the trust provisions would likely govern, rather than the fraudulently executed IRA account beneficiary designation.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan

Undue Influence

If a person names a person as a beneficiary of an IRA account while subject to undue influence, that beneficiary designation is probably void. Undue influence is difficult to define, but is generally regarded as "substituted intent," meaning that one person’s intent is followed rather than another person’s. Assume from the above example that the son had instead told his mother that she was signing a document that changes the beneficiary of the IRA account to him. If the son pressured his mother into naming him rather than another, and if the mother does decide to name her son as the beneficiary, an argument could be made that the son exercised undue influence over his mother. If the argument is successful, a court could void the beneficiary designation of the IRA account and the proceeds from the account would pass under the terms of her trust.

Duress

Duress is an extreme form of undue influence. Duress occurs when a person performs, or threatens to perform, some wrongful act that causes a person to do something that she would not have otherwise done. The important component of duress is that the person is threatening a wrongful act. For example, if a senior citizen’s caretaker threatened to telephone the senior’s children and tell them that their mother died unless the senior signs an IRA beneficiary designation form naming the caretaker as the beneficiary, the beneficiary designation would most likely fail and the trust provisions would govern.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan
How to Dispute a Power of Attorney

References

Related articles

Can a Living Trust Be Disputed?

A living trust is an estate planning tool that allows a person's property to bypass probate court proceedings after death. At the same time, living trusts generally allow people to maintain full control over their assets during their lifetimes. Trusts are governed by state law and, like all legal documents, must comply with applicable statutes. A trust that does not conform with the law may be challenged in court and partially or completely invalidated.

What Is Diversion of Property From a Trust?

Diversion of trust property is a legal term used to describe the misapplication or misuse of trust property. Not only does diversion of trust property violate the terms of the trust itself, but it's often a criminal act. A trust agreement forms a contract between the person who sets up the trust in the first place, the trustee and the beneficiary. The trustee has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of both the trust and its beneficiary.

Last Will & Testament of the Terminally Ill

Because a last will and testament disposes of property when someone dies, courts are careful to make sure that a will is in valid form and that it actually expresses the deceased's wishes. When someone makes or changes a will while dying of a terminal illness, special concerns arise concerning the dying person's mental competence.

LegalZoom. Legal help is here. Start Here. Wills. Trusts. Attorney help.

Related articles

What Is a Waiver of Process & Consent to Probate?

When a person leaves a will at his death, the will generally must be probated before the deceased's assets can be ...

What Are the Elements of a Family Trust?

A family trust is perhaps the most common type of trust created today. As its name suggests, a family trust is designed ...

Can I Refuse to Accept an IRA if I Am Designated as the Beneficiary?

Under normal circumstances, beneficiaries are more than eager to collect their inheritance. In some circumstances, ...

What Happens if a Beneficiary Becomes Mentally Incompetent?

The mental incompetency of a beneficiary can create complications for the trustee of a trust or anyone else who stands ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED