Contesting a Probate Administrator

By Beverly Bird

Dying without a will can leave your heirs unhappy in more ways than one. When an individual dies intestate, the court takes over to determine how his estate is settled. The court decides who receives his property, distributing it to his closest living relatives. More distant kin and friends usually receive nothing. The same applies to appointing an administrator -- the individual who oversees the probate process. The court decides who will manage the estate, usually choosing from among the decedent's closest kin. Other heirs may not be happy with the choice.

Statutory Administrators

Statutory provisions regarding who is entitled to act as administrator usually mirror the state’s laws of intestate succession for rights to inherit. For example, in New York and Massachusetts, the decedent’s surviving spouse has first right to the position. If she chooses not to serve, the decedent’s children are next entitled to administer the estate, followed by more distant kin. Generally, the court will appoint one of the decedent’s creditors only if all his known relatives predecease him or don't want the position.

Application Procedure

In most cases, the court will appoint an administrator who has applied for the position. For example, the decedent’s widow might not feel up to the job. One of her children might then petition the court for the right to settle the estate instead. In many jurisdictions, the decedent’s spouse must first waive her right to serve. The decedent’s child then submits a petition to the court, along with her waiver, seeking appointment. The court reviews the petition. If a judge approves it, he gives the applicant permission to serve copies on all other heirs. In most states, he must also publish a notice in the newspaper, alerting any unknown heirs that he seeks the position as well.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan


If the decedent’s other children or relatives object, they have a limited period of time in which to act, usually about 30 days. In most states, they must do so in writing and file the objection with the probate court. One or more heirs might lodge objections. If the court receives any challenges to the appointment, the clerk schedules a hearing. During the proceedings, objectors must “show cause” for their objections and present their arguments to a judge. The judge will either decide to appoint the petitioner anyway, or he will appoint someone else. This individual might be one of the objectors, or it could be someone who never became involved in the debate at all if a judge deems that person more suitable for the position.


Good cause involves admissible grounds. An individual generally cannot object to the petitioner’s request for appointment simply because he wants the job himself. In this case, he can simply file his own petition requesting appointment. To contest the appointment, he must have a statutory reason for his challenge, permissible under his state’s laws. For example, in New York, an objector might allege that the petitioner is incompetent, doesn’t live in the state, is a convicted felon, or prone to substance abuse, dishonesty, or rash decisions. The objector must also prove his allegations.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan
How to Appoint an Executor to Probate in California


Related articles

If There Is No Will, Who Assigns an Executor?

The term "intestacy" refers to a probate situation in which a person dies without a valid will. When this is the case, state law determines how the estate is handled with the probate judge applying state law in his appointment of an executor. Many states refer to executors in intestacy as administrators instead of executors, but the job functions are similar despite the differing terminology.

How Soon After Death Must One Probate a Will in California?

Probate is a legal process by which a person's assets are distributed after death. Probate in California takes place in the Superior Court of the county where the person died. Many, but not all, estates are subject to probate. A personal representative, also called the executor, must petition the court for probate within 30 days after learning of the decedent's death.

Can I Fire the Executor of My Uncle's Will?

Once the probate court has designated an executor to your uncle’s will, it will not likely remove that person from the role. Being rude to you, not acting according to your schedule or making decisions about the estate you don’t agree with are generally not sufficient reasons to remove an executor. However, if you qualify as an interested person, you may be able to have the executor fired if he does something seriously wrong.

LegalZoom. Legal help is here. Start Here. Wills. Trusts. Attorney help. Wills & Trusts

Related articles

What if You Cannot Find Heirs in Succession?

When someone dies without a will to bequeath his property, the law leaves little doubt about who receives the fruits of ...

How to Be the Executor of a Deceased Estate

When a person dies, someone must take on the responsibility of managing the decedent’s estate through the probate ...

Can an Heir Be Deleted From a Property Inheritance?

When someone leaves a will, he can bequeath his property to anyone he chooses. With the exception of his spouse in some ...

Ways to Contest a Will in Alabama

Alabama courts seek to ensure that a person's estate is distributed according to his wishes. If the will does not ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED