The Difference Between a Constructive Trust and an Equitable Lien

By Erika Johansen

Constructive trusts and equitable liens are two types of remedies designed to prevent one person from unjustly benefiting from the money or property of another. These legal remedies require a court order, and procedures vary from state to state. In many jurisdictions, you will need an attorney to seek a constructive trust or equitable lien.

Constructive Trust

A court imposes a constructive trust when a defendant is reaping benefit from property that he acquired unfairly. The constructive trust effectively turns the defendant into a trustee, charged with holding and managing the property, but unable to reap any benefit from the property. All benefit goes to the plaintiff, who is effectively a secured creditor for the trust. For instance, if John steals money from Tom and then invests the money in a life insurance policy, a constructive trust will give Tom all right to the benefits from the policy. In cases like this, Tom will usually need to "trace" the funds, meaning he will need to present accounting evidence to the court to prove that his money was used to purchase the insurance policy.

Equitable Lien

Equitable liens are used when the defendant has either wrongfully acquired someone else's property, or has made improvements to a piece of property using funds he obtained unfairly. When this happens, the defendant owes a debt to the plaintiff. The equitable lien uses the property to secure the debt. For instance, Annie leads Sally to believe that they jointly own a piece of property. Sally spends a considerable amount of her own money to improve the property, but then finds out Annie deceived her and Annie owns the property outright. At this point, a court might give Sally an equitable lien on the property to make sure that Annie pays her back.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan

Which Remedy Applies?

Both equitable liens and constructive trusts are usually applied when the defendant has somehow taken advantage of a relationship of trust or confidence, for instance, when the defendant has used undue influence, fraud, or abuse of confidence. But a constructive trust only applies when the defendant owns the property at issue. If the defendant has only used his unjust gains to improve other property which he doesn't own, then an equitable lien is the only way for the plaintiff to lay claim to the improved property.

Bona Fide Purchasers

Depending on state law, the holder of a constructive trust or equitable lien usually has first rights to the property, ahead of other creditors. In the future, if someone buys the property, the buyer takes the property "subject to" the trust or lien, meaning that the holder of the trust or lien still has the first rights. But one party will have priority over both a constructive trust and an equitable lien: the bona fide purchaser, or BFP. The BFP is someone who has purchased the property with no knowledge of the lien or the trust. BFP ownership will trump both a constructive trust and an equitable lien, leaving the trust or lienholder with no rights to the property.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan
Can a Sole Beneficiary Refuse His or Her Trust?

References

Resources

Related articles

Difference Between Last Wills and Living Trusts

A person's last will is a document that contains her directions as to what she wants to happen to her property after her death. A living trust, also called an "inter vivos" trust, is a conveyance of property -- during a person's lifetime -- to a trust in order to avoid probate, reduce taxes and other reasons. While wills and inter vivos trusts can both dispose of property, there are many differences between each type of document.

What Is a Second Trust Deed?

A deed of trust is similar to a mortgage, allowing a borrower to secure a loan to buy a house by using the house as collateral. The difference is that in a mortgage there are two parties involved – the borrower and the lender -- while in a trust deed there are three parties involved – the borrower, the lender and a trustee. The trustee, who is generally a title insurance company or a bank, holds the legal title to the property until the loan is paid in full. Depending on where the property is located, state law determines which type of security instrument must be used.

What Is a Quitclaim Covenant?

A quitclaim deed conveys someone’s interest in real property to someone else. The seller or donor is the grantor; the recipient is the grantee. The quitclaim’s only promise, or covenant, is that if the grantor had an interest in the land, that interest is transferred to the grantee. That’s a big “if.” Quitclaims should be used only in special circumstances.

LegalZoom. Legal help is here. Start Here. Wills. Trusts. Attorney help.

Related articles

What Is Diversion of Property From a Trust?

Diversion of trust property is a legal term used to describe the misapplication or misuse of trust property. Not only ...

What is an Assignment of Trust Deed?

If you own a home, you may have signed a trust deed that gives the mortgage lender a claim on the property. A default ...

Can an Irrevocable Trust Be Pierced?

When you create an irrevocable trust, you surrenders ownership over the trust assets; you cannot unilaterally regain ...

Does a Trust Beneficiary Have Standing in a Suit to Determine a Trust Property?

All trusts have trustees and beneficiaries. A trustee's job is to manage, hold and distribute trust assets in favor of ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED