Difference in Guardianship and Custodian

By David Carnes

Custody and guardianship are two types of legal arrangements under which an adult assumes legal authority over and responsibility for the care of someone who cannot care for his own basic needs. Different types of custody and guardianship exist and laws vary by state. The most important difference between custody and guardianship relates to the degree of authority and responsibility vested in the caregiver.

Basics

Parents are considered the natural custodians of their children. As such, courts typically do not deny parents custody except occasionally during divorce proceedings or when a parent is found to be unfit. A guardian is normally appointed for a child when both parents are unavailable or unfit, or for an adult if he is mentally or physically disabled to the extent he cannot provide for his own basic needs. Custodians are never appointed for adults. The legal standard for appointing either a custodian or a guardian is the "best interests" of the ward.

Authority

A person with legal custody over a child, even if someone other than a parent (a stepmother, for example), exercises broad authority over that child equivalent to the responsibilities traditionally held by a parent . A guardian's authority, by contrast, may be limited as circumstances dictate – for example, a guardian's authority may be limited to making medical treatment decisions on behalf of a child. Even if a guardian is appointed for a child, a parent may retain custody rights, such as visitation, which cannot be overruled by the guardian. The authority of a guardian over a disabled adult is limited to the least restrictive authority necessary to provide for the adult's best interests.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Durability

Custody over a minor terminates automatically when the child reaches the age of majority – 18 in most states. Guardianship of a minor, by contrast, lasts only while both of the child's parents are unfit or unavailable. A parent may petition a court to terminate guardianship of a minor in favor of parental custody; a court will grant the petition unless the parent is shown to be unfit to care for the child. Although custodianship may be permanent unless or until circumstances intervene, a guardianship may be temporary in nature. For example, a guardian may be appointed to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a child while his parents are on temporary assignment overseas.

Appointment Procedure

A biological parent requires no legal procedure to obtain custody of his child. Adoption procedures automatically confer custody to the adoptive parent. Except for these circumstances, custody requires a court order while guardianship always requires one. In both types of arrangements, parties opposed to a custody or guardianship petition may oppose it at an adversarial hearing.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Legal Guardianship Procedures

References

Related articles

Difference Between a Guardian and Custody in Michigan

Custody laws primarily focus on the rights of parents while guardianship provides rights to family members or other adults who have taken responsibility for raising children. Although the rights given through guardianship may be similar to parents' custodial rights, the rights granted to a guardian vary from one case to the next. Michigan state law defines several types of guardianship arrangements that may fit a family’s needs and circumstances.

Can a Legal Guardianship Expire?

A guardianship is a legal mechanism by which one individual or entity is appointed by a court to make decisions on behalf of another person. The person in need of guardianship may be a minor whose parents are unwilling or unable to provide proper care for the child, or an adult incapacitated by illness or age. Unless otherwise stipulated by the court, a legal guardianship can expire or terminate; when and how depends on the type of guardianship.

Guardianship Vs. Durable Power of Attorney

No one likes to consider the possibility of becoming physically or mentally incapacitated. However, guardianship and durable power of attorney provide two possible alternatives to ensure the proper handling of your affairs if you are not able to do so for yourself. The two roles are similar, but there are significant differences between them.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

The Rights & Responsibilities of a Temporary Guardian in Arkansas

A temporary guardian is a person appointed by the court to play the legal role of a child's parent, when parents are ...

Is Legal Guardianship the Same as a Custodial Parent in Ohio?

A grandparent or another caregiver who has taken responsibility for raising a child may seek a formal arrangement from ...

What Are the Responsibilities of a Temporary Guardian?

A temporary guardian's job is to provide short-term care for an individual referred to as a ward. Wards may be minor ...

Does a Father Have Rights Even if the Will Gives Guardianship to the Grandparents?

Fathers’ rights almost always trump grandparents’ rights, regardless of what the custodial parent’s will says. Although ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED