Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
If you are filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you may have no assets to forfeit to pay creditors and be in a low-income tax bracket. Although you may not have tangible assets for the bankruptcy trustee to seize, such as a vacation home or jewelry, your tax refund is considered an asset and may be subject to forfeiture. In most states you are permitted to apply state or federal exemptions to some property, preventing it from being taken by the trustee for your creditors. Although these exemptions generally apply to your house or car, Kansas now allows some Chapter 7 debtors to exempt portions of their tax refund.
Kansas State Exemption
In 2011, the Kansas Legislature passed section 60-2315 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated, to allow Chapter 7 debtors to keep a portion of a year's tax refund equal to the debtor's earned income tax credit. This tax credit aids working class taxpayers by refunding any Social Security taxes paid during the year. As the average earned income tax credit in Kansas for 2011 was $2,174, a debtor's ability to keep the refund while in bankruptcy can serve as a big financial boost at a time when money is tight.
The new exemption created a legal controversy when one Kansas state bankruptcy trustee fought the law, claiming it violated the United States Constitution. Specifically, the trustee argued that the Kansas legislature did not have authority to enact legislation overriding US bankruptcy law because federal law is the supreme law of the land. In response to the trustee's challenge, the attorney general of Kansas intervened on behalf of the affected debtors and defended the new exemption. Although the legal challenges are ongoing, the Kansas exemption was found constitutionally valid and upheld by federal bankruptcy and appeals courts.
Impact on Trustee's Pay
Trustees in Kansas, like in most states, receive a small fee of about $60 per case for their services. One way a trustee can increase his fee is through seizing a debtor's asset in a Chapter 7 case, for which he is paid up to a 25 percent commission. Since most Chapter 7 debtors have no assets for liquidation, other than their expected tax refunds, the trustees may be reliant on seizing the debtor's refunds to supplement their own pay. However, the new Kansas exemption law reduces the trustee's own income from the case.