What Kind of Questions Does the Court Ask in Custody Battles?

By Beverly Bird

Custody is one of the murkiest areas of law. It offers few absolute guidelines a judge must follow. All states base custody on the best interests of the children, but most have not set definitive criteria as to what those best interests might be. Often, it’s left up to a judge to interpret the nuances of each family situation.

Existing Custody Arrangement

Having parents break up is difficult enough for children; judges are very reluctant to force additional trauma by radically changing an existing custody arrangement. Expect a judge to ask about the parenting plan you’ve had in place so far, even if it’s informal and not part of an existing court order. He’ll want to know in which home your child has been living most of the time. He’ll ask which of you met your children’s day-to-day needs before you and their other parent separated. The court will want to identify their primary caregiver so his or her presence remains as consistent as possible in their lives. The longer a child has been predominantly in the care of one parent, the more likely it is that the parent will receive physical custody.

Career Questions

Being a single parent can be difficult at times, and the court will want to make sure you’re capable of the job. A judge might ask about your job or career. Can you easily take time off from work if your child is sick and needs you? If the court places your child with you, will he spend a lot of time in daycare? When both parents work, a third-party caregiver is often inevitable, so the court will ask who cares for your child when you’re not available. If the caregiver you use is a family member, the court will usually prefer this to placing your child in a daycare facility.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Your Home and Lifestyle

A judge might also ask about your social and leisure time, and about the character of friends or other individuals who frequently come to your home. A judge will want information about where you’re living. If you’re renting an apartment which you share with a roommate, this may work against you if your ex lives alone in a home with adequate bedroom space for your child. Another consideration is the emotional climate in your home. If you live in a stressful environment, such as if you have older children from another relationship who are constantly fighting or causing problems, this may affect a custody decision as well. The judge will probably ask questions about the home in which your child will live if he gives custody to you.

Your Relationship With Your Ex

Almost every state considers that frequent and loving contact with both parents is in the best interest of a child. Expect a judge to ask if either of you has ever interfered with visitation or done anything to disrupt your child’s relationship with the other. A parent who facilitates his child’s contact with his other parent will usually have an edge in a custody battle, especially if all other factors are equal. When you're in court, take care to answer the judge's questions calmly, truthfully and without obvious malice toward your child’s other parent.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Ideas for Sharing Custody


Related articles

Shared vs. Residential Custody

In most states, two kinds of custody apply to all separating families: legal and physical. Legal custody refers only to major decision-making, and physical custody refers to the parent with whom a child lives. A parent with sole physical custody is sometimes referred to as the residential or custodial parent; this is the parent with residential custody. When a child lives a relatively equal amount of time in each parent’s home, this is referred to as shared custody, also often called joint custody.

Who Qualifies for Joint Custody of a Child?

When they realize divorce is imminent, many parents hope to have joint custody of the children. The term "joint custody" is more complicated than it seems on the surface, however. It can mean different things in different states, but more often than not, it refers to legal custody, which has no bearing on how much time your child spends with you. By any name, courts typically want some assurances before they order it that it’s going to work out. You'll probably have to ask for it in your divorce filings because judges are sometimes reluctant to order joint custody if parents have not expressed a desire for it, or if parent is adamantly opposed to it.

California Laws on Teenage Custody Wishes

Custody determinations often have a significant impact on the life of a child. For that reason, California law provides judges with the discretion to consider a teenager's preference, if the child is capable of making a reasonable choice. Also, teenagers 14 and older may generally participate in the proceedings and offer input, regardless of whether the court ultimately considers the child's preference.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

How Is Child Custody Decided In Divorce?

Every state defers to a concept called the “best interests of the child” when deciding custody issues. But different ...

What Living Arrangements Are Best for Teenagers in a Joint Custody?

Some teenagers who live with joint physical custody arrangements have been doing so since they were young. Others may ...

Can You Go Back to Court for Custody After You Gave Your Child to Your Spouse?

Parents always maintain the right to go back to court to change custody arrangements after their divorce is final. The ...

How to Prepare for a Custody Evaluation

If you and your spouse are contesting custody as part of your divorce, and the judge has decided that a custody ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED