Legal Agreement for Inheritance Money for Siblings

By John Stevens J.D.

Siblings are free to allocate inheritance money in virtually any way they agree to. The question is whether that agreement is legally enforceable if a sibling does not live up to the agreement. This type of agreement is governed by contract law. A contract is an agreement that the law will enforce. A contract is formed only if several requirements are satisfied. Siblings thinking about entering into such an agreement should proceed cautiously, particularly if they decide against seeking the advice of an attorney.

Offer

The formation of every contract begins with an offer. The person who makes an offer is called the “offeror.” An offer is made if the offeror does something that would lead a reasonable person, called the “offeree,” to believe that the parties will have made a bargain if the offeree agrees to the proposal. In this context, an offer might exist if one sibling tells another sibling that she will agree to divide an inheritance equally if the other sibling promises to give up cigarette-smoking, for example. A reasonable person in the offeree’s position (the smoker) would believe that the siblings have reached a bargain if the offeree agrees to the proposal.

Acceptance

A contract is not created unless the offer is accepted. The means of accepting a proposal depend on the terms of the proposal. An offeror might want only a promise in exchange for the offer. Perhaps the offeror instead wants the offeree to actually do something, or to refrain from doing something. From the previous example, if the offeror said, “I will agree to divide the inheritance money equally if you promise to quit smoking,” the offeree would accept the offer if she promised to quit smoking. If instead the offeror said, “I promise to divide the inheritance money equally if you stop smoking,” the offeree would likely have to actually stop smoking to accept the offer.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan

Consideration

An agreement is not a contract unless there was consideration given in exchange for the promise. “Consideration” is something of value to the person making the promise. Consideration can be a return promise to do something or not to do something. If the offeror wants a return promise from his sibling that she will quit smoking, that promise would be consideration for the promise to divide the inheritance money equally. If the offeror instead wanted the sibling to actually quit smoking, the consideration for the promise to divide the inheritance money equally would be the actual cessation of smoking.

Promissory Estoppel as an Alternative

An aggrieved party cannot recover in a breach-of-contract lawsuit if there was never a contract. The theory of promissory estoppel may apply in some situations to provide at least some recovery where no contract was formed. Assume that a sibling promises his sister that he will divide inheritance money equally between them, and that the sister relies on that promise and builds an addition to her house in anticipation of the money. Assume further that the promising sibling later does not distribute the money equally as he had promised. There is no contract here because there is no offer. There is no offer because the promising sibling did not ask for anything in exchange (consideration) for the promise. The doctrine of promissory estoppel provides that a person who reasonably relies on a promise and suffers some harm as a result can receive money to compensate her for her loss. In this situation, a court could order the promising sibling to pay an amount equal to the construction costs incurred by his sister. A court could not order the promising sibling to divide the inheritance money equally under this theory, however.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan
How to Revoke a Prenuptial Agreement
 

References

Related articles

How to Write Children Out of a Will

Most states in the United States allow parents to disinherit their children. An estranged child is only one possible scenario; parents may also cut off one adult child to assist another child who is disabled, in greater need or who helped the parents during the final years of their life. Most jurisdictions permit disinheritance of offspring for any reason, but protect against accidental disinheritance. The key to successfully writing a child out of a will is making clear that you acted deliberately.

What Is Meant by Share and Share-Alike in a Will?

Some legal terms carry their own peculiar definition but others mean exactly what they seem to mean. The expression share and share alike means the same thing in a will that it does on the playground: everyone who is included in the group at the time of distribution gets an equal share of the object or assets in question.

Houses Split Between Siblings in a Will

One of the most common directives in a will reads “my estate shall be divided equally among my children.” While parents have good intentions, their desire for sibling parity often backfires. How do you split a house between two, three or more children? Unfortunately, a parent’s death shifts the family dynamic and sometimes brings out the worst in siblings. Such a situation leaves siblings with four general options.

LegalZoom. Legal help is here. Start Here. Wills. Trusts. Attorney help. Wills & Trusts

Related articles

Husband's Contract to Waive Rights to an Elective Share of a Spouse's Property

Unless other arrangements are made, if a husband is not mentioned in his wife’s will or is bequeathed only a nominal ...

Do Binding Contracts Have to Be Notarized?

Promises alone don't make a binding contract, but you don't need notaries or witnesses either. A legal contract is an ...

Can a Future Inheritance Be Put Into a Divorce Agreement?

It takes two to marry but only one to divorce. If your spouse wants out, you save time and tears by accepting the ...

Can a Prenuptial Agreement Be Voided?

When your marriage is disintegrating and you suspect divorce is looming on the horizon, it can be a big comfort to know ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED