Originality and Copyright Laws

By Grygor Scott

Copyright laws protect a wide range of works, including novels, songs, photographs, movies and computer programs. A copyright holder can file an infringement lawsuit against anyone who uses his work without permission. The issue of originality usually arises in an infringement lawsuit when the defendant claims that the copyright is invalid because the work is not original.

Statutory Requirements

The Copyright Act of 1976 requires copyrighted works to satisfy two basic requirements: They must be “original works of authorship" and be "fixed in any tangible medium of expression.” The fixation requirement is usually straightforward. A work is fixed when a person can perceive it directly or with the aid of a machine or device. Typing, making a recording, or saving a work on a computer disk are common ways to satisfy the fixation requirement. The originality requirement is more complicated.


Federal courts have established a relatively low threshold for originality. In general, originality depends on two factors: whether the author created the work independently and whether the work possesses some degree of creativity. Federal courts have upheld copyrights for works that have displayed minimal creativity. A work satisfies the independent authorship requirement if the author has not copied or paraphrased another work. In theory, a writer could type out "Moby-Dick" word-for-word independently of Herman Melville’s novel and secure a copyright for the work. In practice, the writer would have trouble establishing that he created this exact replication on his own.

Protect against infringement by registering a copyright. Get Started Now

Unoriginal Works

Federal courts have ruled that a variety of works do not qualify for copyright protection because they do not contain original authorship. In most cases, these works consisted entirely of raw data and information available to everyone. Examples of unoriginal works include simple rulers, basic calendars, telephone directories and lists taken from public sources.

The Sweat Theory

Some federal courts have ruled that works containing publicly available factual information are copyrightable if the author has used sufficient intellectual labor -- or "sweat of the brow," as one court wrote -- in creating the work. For example, directories, compilations and maps may be copyrighted if the work’s creator obtains the information through his own efforts. Thus, a cartographer can copyright a map of California that is based on his own research. If the mapmaker has merely copied an existing California map, he cannot claim a valid copyright for his map.

Derivative Works

Derivative works are based on one or more works that already exist. A painting based on a photograph and a collection of short stories translated from French to English are examples of derivative works. The owner of a a derivative work can copyright it if it meets one of two standards: The new work must either contain a substantial amount of new material or differ sufficiently from the existing work. Making minor changes to an existing work will not satisfy the originality requirement. Adding new text or photographs to the existing work or expressing the existing work in a different form, such as choreographing a song, will fulfill the originality requirement so the derivative work will qualify for copyright protection. A copyright for a derivative work covers only the new materials it contains. Its copyright does not protect the pre-existing material or lengthen the length of its copyright.

Protect against infringement by registering a copyright. Get Started Now
What Is Substantial Alteration of a Copyright Infringment?



Related articles

Copyright Issues Involving Music

A piece of recorded music is covered by two copyrights. The copyright in the composition protects the music and lyrics, if any, and is usually owned by the songwriter. The producer or record company owns a separate copyright in the sound recording, which protects the audio engineering and production of the recording. These copyrights provide their owners with the exclusive right to make copies of the music and distribute it to others, perform the music and create derivative works.

Does a Copyright Protect an Author's Creative Idea?

Copyright laws give authors and other creators property rights for their works of original authorship, including the rights to reproduce, distribute, and display their works. One of the fundamental principles of copyright law is that a copyright protects expressions but not creative ideas. Although this basic rule seems straightforward, it may be difficult to apply in some cases.

Copyright Laws for Using Someone Else's Work

A copyright protects original works in tangible form, such as manuscripts, music recordings or computer code, from being used without the owner's permission. Generally, if you want to use all or just a part of a copyrighted work, you must obtain permission from the copyright holder. Failure to do so is copyright infringement, which carries civil and criminal penalties. There is, however, a limited exception known as fair use.

Related articles

Are Commercials Copyrighted?

With the free accessibility of information and creative content over the Internet, it can be hard to know what is ...

How to Copyright in Illinois

Copyright law in the state of Illinois, like all states, is governed by federal law. The U.S. Constitution vests in ...

Are Song Arrangements Copyrighted?

A musical composition copyright protects the music and lyrics of any song from the moment it is either recorded in ...

Can I Record Someone Else's Song and Change the Words in Parody Law?

United States copyright law grants legal protection to various creative works, including songs or lyrics. Under The ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED