What Is the Punishment for Violating a Patent?

By Timothy James

Patent laws encourage creativity by allowing inventors to profit from their inventions. In essence, a patent awards inventors the exclusive right to market, sell or use their inventions. Patents are authorized in Article One, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution. Accordingly, the federal government issues patent laws and sets forth a number of remedies that serve as punishment for those who violate patent rights.

Preliminary Injunction

Because court cases can drag on for years, courts sometimes issue a preliminary injunction at the beginning of litigation. The preliminary injunction serves to prevent the defendant from continuing to violate a patent while the lawsuit is in progress. Because it can destroy a defendant's business, courts will only grant a preliminary injunction if four requirements are met: the plaintiff is reasonably likely to prevail at court; the plaintiff is likely to be irreparably harmed; the threatened harm to the plaintiff outweighs the potential harm to the defendant; and the injunction serves the public interest.

Permanent Injunction

At the conclusion of a lawsuit, a court may choose to issue a permanent injunction. This forbids the defendant from repeating the action that was the subject of the lawsuit. Courts decide whether to issue permanent injunctions based on the same criteria used to decide on issuing preliminary injunctions except that, in addition, the court also checks to ensure that other remedies would not suffice to compensate for the harm. Even if the plaintiff prevails, a court does not necessarily issue a permanent injunction. Sometimes courts rely on other forms of relief.

File a provisional application for patent online. Get Started Now

Compensatory Damages

A court may award a plaintiff several types of compensatory damages that serve to compensate the holder of the patent. First, the court can require a defendant to pay back any profits lost by the holder of the patent. Second, the court can require the defendant to pay the ordinary royalty fees established by the patent holder. Finally, in the absence of an established royalty program, the defendant may have to pay the amount that the infringer likely would have paid if a royalty program had been in place.

Punitive Damages and Attorneys Fees

Courts award punitive damages, sometimes called "enhanced damages," when they find that a defendant knowingly and deliberately chose to ignore existing patent laws, without any reasonable basis for doing so. Punitive damages can amount to as much as three times the amount of ordinary compensatory damages. In very rare cases, a court might also require payment of attorney's fees by the losing party when the outcome of the case was especially obvious to the court from the commencement of litigation.

File a provisional application for patent online. Get Started Now
How Are Copyright Laws Enforced?
 

References

Related articles

Can Products Be Similar Without Violating Patent Laws?

Products can be very similar without violating patent laws because patents do not protect products. Patents protect inventions. This subtle distinction explains why very similar products do not automatically violate patent laws. If you believe your invention is so similar to another that it might infringe on the invention, you should consider consulting legal counsel or an online legal service because the penalties for infringement can be very steep.

What Can Legally Happen to Someone if They Commit Copyright Infringement?

Under U.S. law, a copyright automatically attaches to an original work of authorship as soon as it is reduced to tangible form. If the copyright holder registers the work with the U.S. Copyright Office, the copyright is easier to enforce and additional remedies are available. Copyright infringement can result in both civil and criminal penalties.

What Happens When Someone Tries to Use a Patent That Has Expired?

While in effect, a patent offers the holder exclusive rights to his invention. But a patent can expire for two reasons: failure to pay maintenance fees or completion of the natural patent term. What happens when someone makes or uses a patented invention that has expired depends upon why the patent expired.

Start here. LegalZoom. Legal help is here. LLCs. Corporations. Patents. Attorney help. Patents

Related articles

What Violates a Patent?

Innovation drives success but also can breed danger. If you make or sell a device or process that resembles a patented ...

What Happens When You Violate a Patent?

Patent rights are so important the founding fathers mentioned them in the U.S. Constitution. This respect for patent ...

Consequences for Violations of the Copyright Laws

Copyright laws are in place to protect the creators of proprietary written works, images, music and a range of other ...

Overturning a Patent

A patent is a right to exclude others from making, using or selling an invention of yours. To be eligible for patent ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED