Reasons for Contesting a Will

By Brian Richards

To challenge a will, you must have a specific legal reason. It is insufficient merely to state that you believe you are entitled to a larger share of the estate; you must select one of a handful of legal grounds on which to base your contest. While an attorney can evaluate your situation and determine whether you have a sufficient reason to challenge a will, you may also file a will contest yourself.

Incapacity

At the time an individual signs his will, he must have the mental capacity to understand the nature of his action. When the individual does not have the requisite capacity, the will may be successfully challenged. Though each state defines legal capacity slightly differently, the main factors generally include the individual's ability to understand the meaning of the will, the property he is giving away and the beneficiaries to whom he is giving his property. The mental state at the moment the individual signed the will is all that is relevant; his mental capacity before signing, after signing and at death are all irrelevant. It is possible for an individual to be only temporarily incapacitated. For a successful will contest, the challenger has the burden to prove incapacity at the time the will was signed.

Formalities

Each state has its own requirements as to how a will must be drafted to be legal. Failing to meet even a single required formality is enough to provide grounds for a will challenge. For instance, while some states allow holographic wills -- documents that are in the deceased's own handwriting and signed at the bottom -- many require that witnesses sign the document before the will is valid. If the will has no witnesses, it may be successfully challenged. Some states require that the witnesses be disinterested parties, which means they are not beneficiaries under the will. All states require that the will be drafted when the individual is at least 18 years old, though many provide exceptions in the event that the individual is in the armed forces or married.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan

Fraud or Undue Influence

A will must be an accurate portrayal of the deceased's true wishes. If another individual has influenced her decisions during the will-making process, you may be able to challenge the will. Not all outside influence will invalidate the document, however. To support a valid challenge, the influence must come from a person in a position of trust who has benefited in the will from his influence. For instance, a caregiver who withholds medication from the individual until she signs a will giving all her property to the caregiver would be committing undue influence. Fraud, in which the deceased was deceived in some way into signing a will or including provisions in her will that she did not intend, is also sufficient to uphold a will contest.

Will Revocation

An individual may revoke his will in a variety of ways. A new will is generally assumed to supersede an older will, and a successful will contest may be based upon the existence of a new will. An individual may also expressly revoke his will by drafting a new document expressing that he no longer wishes his will to be valid. Divorce or marriage may also invalidate a will, as probate courts are reluctant to rely on a document that was drafted when the deceased was in a very different familial situation.

Protect your loved ones. Start My Estate Plan
How to Prove a Will Is Genuine

References

Related articles

What Happens When a Living Trust Is Contested?

When a decedent creates a trust, which courts refer to as a living trust, in lieu of drafting a will, the terms of the trust name beneficiaries and the trust assets they are each eligible to receive. However, the terms of a living trust are vulnerable to contests or challenges in state probate court by parties who claim the living trust is invalid because it violates state trust law.

What Is a Legal Will in the State of North Carolina?

Wills in North Carolina can take many forms, depending on the circumstances. However, for each form of will to be declared valid by a North Carolina probate court, the will must conform to the requirements of the North Carolina state code Chapter 31 for the type of will being used.

Can You Contest a Will When the Testator Was Medicated?

Testamentary capacity is perhaps one of the most-cited reasons for challenging the validity of a will during probate, and for good cause. Capacity directly affects a testator’s legal ability to make a will, which is why every state defines strict statutory guidelines describing mental competency. Most states do permit claimants to contest a will on grounds of diminished or lacking testamentary capacity if the testator was under the influence of mind-altering medication. However, medication affects each individual differently, so the courts must examine the testator’s state of mind and the actual effects of the medication on a case-by-case basis.

LegalZoom. Legal help is here. Start Here. Wills. Trusts. Attorney help.

Related articles

What Makes a Will Legal & Binding?

When executed wholly and correctly, a will is a legal document that supersedes any other document, contract or verbal ...

Annulment Requirements

Divorce constitutes an end to a marriage, while an annulment deems a marriage never existed. Over time, however, the ...

Can a Trust Override a Beneficiary in an IRA Bank Account?

A trust is a legal device by which property is distributed to beneficiaries named in the trust. Although property held ...

How to Dispute a Power of Attorney

When a person creates a power of attorney, she allows a trusted person named in the document to act on her behalf and, ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED