Are Recorded Conversations Legal in Divorce Court?

By Teo Spengler

"He said, she said" can typify arguments between embattled spouses, where each accuses the other of communications the other denies. It may seem that recording conversations would resolve divorce issues quickly, but this is not always true. Recordings of private conversations, even when legally made, are not admissible evidence in civil courts in all states.

Legality of Recording

The recording of private conversations is regulated by most states. Before you rush out to record a conversation with your spouse, check your state's laws about the legality of doing so. Most states apply the "one-party" consent rule, making the recording legal if at least one party consents. A minority of states require that all parties consent to a recording before a conversation can legally be recorded.

Admissibility of Recording

Even if you record a private conversation legally, you may not be able to introduce it in divorce court. Laws about the admissibility of audio recordings vary among the states. For example, Wisconsin statutes declare most such evidence totally inadmissible in civil cases, with only very limited exceptions. In New York, however, legally obtained audio recordings can be admissible if a proper showing is made: that is, the courts require proof that the recording is genuine and that nobody has tampered with it.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Is a Written Last Will & Testament a Legal Document?
 

References

Related articles

What Does a Legal Will Look Like?

A legal will is a will that meets the requirements in state law for the will to be recognized by that state. Each U.S. state has its own rules about legal wills, though many states have similar rules. A legal will often looks like many other legal documents. To recognize a legal will, you will need to understand the basic requirements to make a will legal in your state.

How to Make a Last Will Tape Recording

A recording of your last wishes does not constitute a valid will in any state, at least not when it stands alone. A great many individuals record their wills anyway, as a safeguard against will contests and other eventualities that might result in the probate court not honoring their bequests. Video- and audio-recorded wills generally enforce or back up your written will. If you don’t also leave a written will, most state courts will rule that you died without one.

Sound Recordings & Copyright Law

Section 102 of the U.S. Copyright Act includes sound recordings as a category of “original works of authorship” eligible for copyright protection. Like any other category, a sound recording is protected by copyright from the moment it is “fixed in any tangible means of expression.” Under the 1976 Copyright Act, copyright protection exists regardless of registration of a copyright claim or publication of the work.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

Are Handwritten Wills Legal in Louisiana If Not Notarized?

Under Louisiana law, an olographic will is one written, signed and dated entirely in the handwriting of the testator, ...

Can You Ask for Copies of Power of Attorney Through the Courts?

Despite what you may have seen in Perry Mason reruns, astonishing court revelations are not the norm. The modern ...

Are Video Wills Legal?

The statutes of very few states contain specific legislation addressing whether video wills are legal. In legal terms, ...

Can a Power of Attorney Sign a Will?

A power of attorney grants one person the legal authority to act on behalf of another for certain purposes, which are ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED