How to Split an IRA in a Divorce Proceeding

By Mark Kennan

IRAs accumulated during a marriage may be considered marital property, even though the account is in the name of only one spouse. During a divorce, all or a portion of one spouse's IRA may be awarded to the other spouse as part of the division of marital property. Since early distributions from IRAs result in taxes and, possibly, additional penalties, knowing the requirements for a tax-free transfer due to a divorce can save a large sum of money.

Penalties for Early IRA Wirthdrawals

If a transfer due to a divorce is not done correctly, the amount of the transfer could be considered a taxable distribution.Distributions of previously untaxed amounts from IRAs are taxed as ordinary income in the year in which they are received. In addition, if the taxpayer is under 59 1/2 years old, the distribution is subject to a 10 percent penalty tax on early distributions. The entire tax burden for this falls on the taxpayer taking the distribution. In addition, if an ex-spouse receives money through a nonqualified transfer, the ex-spouse cannot roll it into her IRA, because it is not an eligible rollover.

Required Court Order

To avoid taxation,the agreement to transfer a portion of an IRA to an ex-spouse must be done according to Section 71(b)(2)(A) divorce or separation instrument of the Internal Revenue Code. This means the spouses must include the order to transfer the IRA in a decree of divorce or separate maintenance, or a written instrument incident to such a decree. For example, a simple verbal agreement between spouses getting a divorce would not qualify.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More

Methods of Transfering an Interest in an IRA

The IRS allows two methods to transfer an interest in an IRA between ex-spouses. First, the financial institution can change the name on the IRA from the owner of the IRA to the name of the ex-spouse. However, this applies only if all the assets in the IRA are being transferred to the ex-spouse. If only a portion of the IRA is being transferred, the IRA money can be moved through a direct transfer from the IRA owned by one spouse to the IRA owned by the other spouse. A direct transfer occurs when the financial institution moves the money straight from one IRA to the other without either spouse receiving cash. A rollover, which occurs when money is paid out to the IRA owner and then redeposited in another IRA, is not a permissible method in the case of divorce.

Prohibited Transactions

Do not take a distribution from your IRA and then give the proceeds to your ex-spouse. In Jones v. Commissioner, the Tax Court has held that this is not a valid way to transfer an IRA interest due to divorce. The Court held that the taxpayer was not transferring an interest in an IRA, because the taxpayer had taken the money out of the IRA. Since the taxpayer was simply transferring cash to the ex-spouse, the court refused to treat it as a transfer due to divorce. Therefore, the attempted transfer was considered a taxable distribution and was subject to taxes and the additional 10 percent tax.

Divorce is never easy, but we can help. Learn More
Who Pays the Taxes When Early Annuity Distribution Is Part of a Divorce Settlement?
 

References

Related articles

How to Avoid IRA Early Withdrawal Penalties in a Divorce

Because IRAs are tax-deferred accounts until you retire and tap into them, it makes sense that if you take the money early, the IRS will assess a 10 percent penalty. However, some circumstances, such as divorce, can force you to access the money well before you planned to and before age 59½, when you could normally take it without paying the 10 percent penalty. Fortunately, the IRS understands this and makes allowances for it.

Inheritance of a Traditional or Roth IRA

If you’ve inherited an individual retirement arrangement, or IRA, it comes with restrictions on when the money must be distributed from the account. Failure to distribute the correct amounts in the correct years carries a stiff penalty – 50 percent of the amount not withdrawn. Knowing the rules will help you maximize the tax-free growth offered by the IRA while avoiding income tax penalties.

Dividing a Variable Annuity in a Divorce Settlement

When you buy an annuity, you enter into a contract with an insurance company for future payments. In a variable annuity, rather than having a set amount for future payments, the payments depend on the earnings made by annuity investments. Variable annuities are tax-deferred so that investment earnings are not taxed until the owner gets the money. Dividing a variable annuity in a divorce without unintended adverse tax consequences is tricky. A financial professional and divorce attorney can help ensure the asset is divided to reach the intended result.

Get Divorced Online

Related articles

How Is a Roth IRA Divided in a Divorce?

Dividing most retirement accounts in a divorce can be a major headache, but Roth IRAs are an exception. Unlike defined ...

Can an IRA Be Cashed Out During a Divorce?

There are a lot of reasons why you might want to lay your hands on some cash when you're going through a divorce. ...

Inherited IRA Beneficiary Management Guide

When someone dies with money still in an IRA, the money passes to the named beneficiary of the account. The Internal ...

401(k) Rights in a Divorce

One of the most difficult aspects of property division in a divorce case concerns the sharing of retirement assets. ...

Browse by category
Ready to Begin? GET STARTED